Lets discuss everyones’s Alter Ego

Lisa is famous from being a member of Kpop group BlackPink who are known for songs that listeners described as ‘making you feel like a bad bitch’. Lisa is a main rapper within the group and often has a cool ‘swaggy’ vibe about her; she dances hiphop/commerically and that is her artist identity. The members of this girl group decided to take a year break from group releases and activities to nurture their own music careers. Some of them wrote music that seems personal and somewhat vulnerable. Then there’s Lisa. She dove deep into her art style, exploring different genres ranging from pop, hiphop, dance-pop, trap and little bit more. She created five alter egos where she can interchange between them when she wants to convey a different artistic side of her. This could include exploration in vocal tones and deliveries, mood and genres.

Solo Artistic Identity

In the modern day music industry, some can argue that it is over-saturated with artists, both signed and independent. The way an artist can be defined and have a concentrated amount of audience, would be through a specified niche. A box or category that sums up the artist’s music and aesthetic in less than five words. Although these niches can be easier for the listeners to decipher between, this can be quite limiting for the artist if they wanted to venture out of their primary genre; in what I think would’ve been a smart move from Lisa, other people beg to differ. With the creation of these alter egos, Lisa can create songs blending other genres more seamlessly whilst still being identifiable. Critics thought that this idea portrayed through her debut solo album was cringe or childish.

Artistic Confidence

In Lisa’s newly released documentary, she opens up about her low confidence with singing which stemmed from her training days under YG Entertainment. She was discouraged from singing when executing her evaluations and was pushed into the box of the main rapper of the group. During those years she managed to perfect her role and personality, which made the world fall in love with who she is in the group (main dancer and lead rapper). Now that she has gone solo, one could argue that there is an expectation for her to continue her persona and visual identity. Carrying the essence of BlackPink is a positive business move, especially since the fans (Blinks) are craving for more releases from the group- it would encourage engagement and sales. In the debut of Lisa’s solo album, many of the tracks include singing sections that shows off her sweet and soft tone; a newly developed side to her artistry. The rest of her album is amplified with rap styles in different genres.

It can be possible that she chose to dominate this album with rap because she has nurtured that art to the point where that style is what she naturally gravitates towards when catering to her audience. However, as time passes on from when Lisa released her first solo song within Blackpink and to now, where she is on her solo ventures, chatter surrounding her lyric topics grew louder.

Repetitive music

What is your reason for listening to music? Mine is to feeeeel. To dance and embrace my emotions that I share with an artist within a song. Each artist has a lane, niche or topic that they frequent in. I love to sing about love and the different experiences I live through due to it. Love is my umbrella topic and under that umbrella, I convey that message through different songs. With each melody, there are lyrics that hold different meanings.

A lot of hiphop rappers, they mostly talk about drugs, sex, money and women- drill rappers mostly rap about street life and drugs. The fact the songs sound different and the lyrics change slightly is what defers the audience from applying criticism to all other artists, but Lisa has been criticised for being repetitive in the topics of her songs.

Hair & Comb Salon Chit Chat podcast

A standout topic that’s recurrent in her singles and albums is money and how she is living a lavish lifestyle. The common comments asks if there is anything else she could talk about in her songs, suggesting an emotional/vulnerable side to her music. Hair & Comb expands more on this topic as commentators who listened to Kpop in their core teenage-young adult years. This is what they had to say:

From the perspective of Shaquilla, she writes songs that tend to be very literal; topics based around her life and/or what happens around her. “I guess I can say I write more on the serious side of things- of life and as much as I can do that and appreciate other artists from within that sector, I feel like I would also want a break from it and put on music that is there for fun, that you can let loose to and puts you in a mood. I feel like that Ying and Yang combo is what is needed for a balance in music in general.”

In terms of use of the Alter Egos, “ I feel like Lisa wants to flow through many genres or artistic rapping/singing styles she can without having them linked so she uses the Alter Egos to be in pocket with each one.”

Amina feels like the way Lisa introduced the alter egos was corny, alluding to the character description of Vixi ‘drinking peoples tears’. It makes us question who the target audience is in terms of age demographics. She has songs that use profanity and mature topics which would make it seem like her target audience starts from 18-25 but then character descriptions such as Vixi’s can feel like she is targeting a younger audience starting from ages 14-15 which can be confusing to the public. A way that the introduction to these alter egos could have been improved would be by creating a short film showcasing the different musical genres they play a role in. It also clarifies the target audience by the narrative tone of the film and musical era that Lisa is stepping into.

It feels as though Lisa created the personas because she was put into a persona ‘box’ from the group BlackPink where she takes on the role of a rapper with a ‘swaggy’ style. She has little to almost no singing lines within the group, as mentioned above, so she is naturally underdeveloped in that skill compared to rapping which (when she goes solo), can be a sensitive area in her musicianship. Overall, that would make sense as to why she would make a persona; as a form of protection.

Good move for business?

It could be a good business move to continue this persona outside of BlackPink because that’s what the fans are used to, especially the fans who derive from the girl group originally. Whilst BlackPink were in their prime releasing schedule, Lisa also released some solo songs where she talks about money and herself in tracks like ‘Money’ and ‘LALISA’ which initially received good reception from the audience. So where did she start to disconnect with her audience?

‘New Woman’ was the second single released ahead of her album ‘Alter Ego’ in collaboration with Rosalia. Later that year, a collaboration with Raye and Doja Cat titled ‘Born Again’. Both songs were around the general topics of women empowerment and rebirth, catching the attention of audiences from Raye, Doja and Roslia.

You could argue that the new audience gained from the collaborations, blended with Lisa’s core audience favoured this side of Lisa’s musicality where it felt like a resurgence of the essence of BlackPink’s ‘badass’ energy; only more developed and mature. Listeners who have been with artists from the beginning of their career yearn to see and hear artistic growth as they too, grow and mature alongside them. It could be that Lisa creating these personas with descriptions such as Vixi, and singing about money and lavish lifestyles is reverting back to when she released ‘Money’ in 2021.

Amina feels as though Lisa’s current music isn’t as ‘musically charged’ as she wants it to be as it feels like ‘a business’. A question that Shaquilla posed was “why is it that deep that her fans feel like she isn’t being vulnerable enough?” What if that is not the type of artist she is?

Amina feels like it’s because she has a big feminine-feeling fan base but the reason why this ‘repetitive music’ works for (male) rappers is because their audience looks up to the idea of making money, cars and having sex - that lifestyle- Men have not been conditioned from a young age to be naturally sensitive and to connect with things on an emotional level although, every human being has the potential to be sensitive and to feel emotional, its about how it’s nurtured and how it’s created. With Lisa’s fanbase which live in that idea to be close, especially if she has a really large gay fanbase- connecting with them in a way that is really useful for career longevity. Rappers tend to die out after a while because..what more can they rap about?

It is understandable that Lisa could get stuck in a difficult place of where she can go with her music because people will never be happy. So this leads us to the question:

Everyone says music is subjective but do you think there’s an invisible criteria an artist has to follow for their music to be accepted by mass audiences?

Next
Next

Top 5 MUST-HAVE songs for your playlist!